When Everyone Does It, Who Asks Whether It Is Right?
Oct 8, 2026
Fort Myers, Florida Oct 8, 2026 (Issuewire.com) - HEALTHCARE IN THE UNITED STATES
ARTICLE 4
When Everyone Does It, Who Asks Whether It Is Right?
Suppose every major seller in a market begins behaving in much the same way. No one admits to fixing prices. No secret agreement is found. Each participant can say, "We are doing what everyone else does." Is that competition?
No responsible discussion should begin by accusing doctors, hospitals or insurers of corruption simply because their practices resemble one another.
Conscious Parallelism and Interdependence
Economists and antitrust lawyers use conscious parallelism for situations in which firms in a concentrated market may independently follow similar pricing or business behavior. It is associated with the interdependence theory of oligopoly pricing: each major participant knows its best move may depend upon what the few other major participants will do.
Parallel behavior alone does not prove an illegal agreement. Businesses may lawfully react to competitors, common costs, public information or government rules. Antitrust law requires evidence and careful application of the governing legal standard.
The Danger of "Normal"
A practice repeated for years can begin to look proper simply because everyone recognizes it. A hospital administrator may use the same contracting structure as neighboring systems. An insurer may adopt the same network practice as competitors. Each can believe, "This is how healthcare works."
That does not make the practice illegal. But widespread acceptance does not make a practice legal if the governing law says otherwise.
No one has to think of himself as corrupt for a harmful system to continue. Sometimes it continues because everyone assumes someone else has already decided it is proper.
Healthcare Should Not Receive a Different Legal Standard
Medicine deserves special trust, but financial organizations surrounding medicine should not receive immunity from competition laws applied elsewhere. Healthcare should be treated fairly: neither presumed guilty because prices are complicated nor excused from examination because its mission is respected.
Negotiated Prices, Steering and Market Power
Networks can reduce prices and coordinate care. They can also raise competition questions when restrictions exclude rivals or reduce meaningful patient choice. Different prices are not automatically illegal price discrimination. Steering is not automatically unlawful. Negotiation is not automatically collusion.
If regulators never ask because a practice is common, the public may never learn whether the practice is beneficial, harmful, lawful or unlawful.
NEXT IN THE SERIES: The Money We See -- and the Money We Don't.
Editor's note: This series distinguishes documented facts and established law from allegations, disputed interpretations and the author's proposed legal, tax and economic theories.
Source :Roy J. Meidinger
This article was originally published by IssueWire. Read the original article here.
More News
NEET candidate above 70, panel seeks age cap, attempt limits
A parliamentary panel has put forth innovative proposals aimed at reforming NEET, JEE (Main), and CUET to enhance examination efficiency and fairness. Key recommendations include a two-stage testing approach and the adoption of computer-based assessments. Additionally, the panel emphasizes the need for greater oversight of the coaching sector to ensure transparency and prioritize students' mental well-being.
NEET candidate above 70, panel seeks age cap, attempt limits
A parliamentary panel has put forth innovative proposals aimed at reforming NEET, JEE (Main), and CUET to enhance examination efficiency and fairness. Key recommendations include a two-stage testing approach and the adoption of computer-based assessments. Additionally, the panel emphasizes the need for greater oversight of the coaching sector to ensure transparency and prioritize students' mental well-being.
Trump says Russia to immediately supply 300,000 tons of diesel fuel
Russia has committed to supply over 300,000 tons of diesel fuel immediately to the global market. Following this, it plans to deliver 3 million tons based on refinery conditions. Additionally, Russia will provide another 500,000 tons in November and 1 million tons shortly thereafter. This agreement emerged from a successful dialogue between Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin. The delivery timeline aims to stabilize fuel availability amidst global demand.
Government scared, protest will go ahead, says Abhijeet Dipke
Abhijeet Dipke, founder of the Cockroach Janata Party, has announced an upcoming protest at Jantar Mantar, Delhi, calling for the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. Despite the Delhi Police's restrictions and metro station closures, the protest will continue. Dipke slammed the government for its anxiety over youth-led demonstrations, stating that the current clampdown is reminiscent of the emergency period when dissent was heavily suppressed.
Rahul Gandhi's politics seems to depend on foreign support: BJP
BJP spokesperson Siddharth Yadav has raised concerns regarding Rahul Gandhi's recent engagement with foreign billionaires. He suggested that Gandhi's politics now rely on international figures for support and funding. Yadav referenced Gandhi's historical criticisms of foreign influence on India's democracy during media interactions. He questioned the shift in the Congress party's stance towards Starlink, contrasting it with their previous opposition.
Cricket: Shai Hope, Sherfane Rutherford fire West Indies to record T20 chase of 250
After India posted 249-5 batting first, the West Indies rode on a 120-run fourth-wicket partnership between Hope, who hit an unbeaten 102, and Rutherford (84) to achieve the target with nine balls to spare in Ranchi. Hope completed the win with the ninth six of his innings and one that brought up his century off 45 balls, as the West Indies bounced back to level the five-match series at 1-1.
Don't use hammer to kill a fly: SC on curbs ahead of CJP's protest
The Supreme Court has ordered the authorities to reassess proposed restrictions on public transport. Metro services must not be completely suspended, ensuring commuters have access. Authorities should only regulate movement as necessary, rather than impose complete bans. The court emphasized that measures should be proportional to the situation, promoting public movement. This decision aims to address the challenges faced by students and other commuters during the planned protest.
Don't use hammer to kill a fly: SC on curbs ahead of CJP's protest
The Supreme Court has ordered the authorities to reassess proposed restrictions on public transport. Metro services must not be completely suspended, ensuring commuters have access. Authorities should only regulate movement as necessary, rather than impose complete bans. The court emphasized that measures should be proportional to the situation, promoting public movement. This decision aims to address the challenges faced by students and other commuters during the planned protest.
More than just football: How scandal-tainted City led Manchester's rebirth
Before City -- now embroiled in the biggest financial scandal to hit football's cash-rich Premier League -- moved to the area it was "very deprived" with high rates of unemployment, he said. Since the club's takeover by deep-pocketed Abu Dhabi investors in 2008, long-neglected districts between the stadium and the city centre have become symbols of the northern city's rebirth.
I'm anti-monopoly, not anti-business, says Rahul Gandhi
Rahul Gandhi stated that he is not against business but is opposed to monopolies in India. He emphasized the importance of a fair playing field for all businesses, large and small. Gandhi criticized the government's alignment with specific businesses, advocating for a more balanced approach. He reaffirmed his commitment to ensuring that no single entity dominates the market.
YOUR NEWS, OUR NETWORK.
Do you have Great News you want to tell the world?
Be it updates about your business or your community, you can make sure that it’s heard by submitting your story to our network reaching hundreds of news sites across 6 verticals.