India’s top court allows bull-taming sport to continue despite criticism from animal rights groups
May 18, 2023
India’s top court has ruled to allow the continuation of the bull-taming sport of jallikattu, which is celebrated as cultural heritage in the southern state of Tamil Nadu but criticized by animals rights groups
NEW DELHI (AP) — India’s top court on Thursday ruled to allow the continuation of the bull-taming sport of jallikattu, which is celebrated as cultural heritage in the southern state of Tamil Nadu but criticized by animals rights groups.
Five justices held that the state government was taking sufficient steps to reduce the pain and suffering of the animals, and ruled the sport and other bull races in the country could continue.
Animal rights organizations had filed court petitions saying jallikattu is a bloodsport and dangerous, with the bulls often attacking their riders and bystanders as they try to escape crowded areas.
The sport, which dates back centuries, is extremely popular in Tamil Nadu during the four-day Pongal harvest festival in January in which hundreds of bull vaulters compete in a carnival-like festival.
As drums beat and the crowd cheers, a man leaps onto the back of a large bull and hangs on tightly to its hump as the animal bucks and jumps. If he can hold on for three jumps or 30 seconds, or for a distance of 15 meters (49 feet), he has a chance to win prizes such as cooking pots, clothes, bicycles, motorbikes or even cars.
Poorvi Joshipura, a spokesperson for PETA India, said the court verdict "makes our country look regressive in the eyes of the world."
People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, a global animal rights organization, was a complainant in India’s top court demanding a stop to the sport in the country.
Joshipura said the court order came despite people and animals dying and sustaining injuries.
"Since 2017, at least 104 men and children and 33 bulls have died. More deaths will occur," she said, adding that other countries have been moving to ban such sports.
The Supreme Court in 2014 had held that jallikattu violated the rights of the animals and the Prevention of Cruelty Act.
Two years later, the federal government carved out an exception for jallikattu and bullock cart races from the scope of the PCA. Animal rights organizations then challenged the move in the Supreme Court.
Later, the Tamil Nadu state government also enacted a law saying it was taking steps to prevent cruelty to the animals, paving the way for jallikattu to continue.
On Thursday, the top court upheld the federal and state governments' actions.
MORE NEWS
US, Canada see growing interest in limited ceasefire in Black Sea
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio highlighted the growing interest in a limited ceasefire in the Black Sea. He emphasized the importance of facilitating grain shipments while pressing for a broader settlement of the ongoing war. Canadian Foreign Minister Anita Anand confronted Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov about Russia's invasion of Ukraine during the G20 meeting.
Four hotel workers die after inhaling toxic gas in Ujjain
Four hotel employees tragically died after inhaling toxic gas while cleaning a food waste tank. Two individuals entered the tank to clean it, after which two more attempted a rescue. A gas leak likely made the surface slippery, leading to the collapses of the individuals. Other staff members who entered the chamber were rescued and transported to the hospital. Authorities are working to gather more details about the incident.
Four hotel workers die after inhaling toxic gas in Ujjain
Four hotel employees tragically died after inhaling toxic gas while cleaning a food waste tank. Two individuals entered the tank to clean it, after which two more attempted a rescue. A gas leak likely made the surface slippery, leading to the collapses of the individuals. Other staff members who entered the chamber were rescued and transported to the hospital. Authorities are working to gather more details about the incident.
Russia surpasses France in African youth appeal, still trails China: survey
Russia’s influence has surged among young people across Africa in recent years, leaping over former colonial power France while still trailing China, a survey of African youths has found. Many young Africans now perceive Russia to be an ally, observers said, warning its rivals to take the shift seriously as the continent becomes increasingly critical to both Moscow and Beijing. According to the African Youth Survey commissioned by the South Africa-based Ichikowitz Family Foundation, 54 per cent...
Who won the Canelo vs Mbilli fight? Canelo's comeback, judges' scores and what happened in Riyadh
In a spectacular return, Saul 'Canelo' Alvarez dominated the boxing ring, regaining his world title with a solid win over Christian Mbilli in Riyadh. After a year off and a tough defeat to Terence Crawford, Alvarez's comeback is nothing short of remarkable. His extraordinary technique and seasoned composure reaffirm his position among the sport's elite fighters.
US judge dismisses Trump lawsuit against Wall Steet Journal over Epstein letter
A US judge dismissed Donald Trump's defamation lawsuit against the Wall Street Journal and Rupert Murdoch. The lawsuit stemmed from a report about a letter Trump sent to Jeffrey Epstein in 2003. Trump's legal team failed to prove that the defendants acted with actual malice in their reporting. The ruling prevents Trump from amending his lawsuit further.
Trump discusses Iran with Netanyahu as US weighs fresh strikes: Report
In a recent discussion, US President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu reviewed the evolving situation with Iran, considering various military strategies. Secretary of State Marco Rubio acknowledged ongoing diplomatic engagement with Iran, highlighting the goal of achieving a peaceful resolution while protecting US security. In contrast, Iranian Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei has issued stern warnings, asserting military repercussions for any provocation from the US or Israel.
Agencies cite jurisdictional limits after Delhi shoe factory fire kills four
A fire at a shoe factory in Mangolpuri Industrial Area resulted in four fatalities and two injuries. The factory had valid licenses and a NOC from the pollution control committee. Initial investigations suggested negligence by laborers as a potential fire cause, although further inquiries are ongoing. The Delhi Fire Service deployed multiple fire tenders to control the blaze, which lasted several hours.
Agencies cite jurisdictional limits after Delhi shoe factory fire kills four
A fire at a shoe factory in Mangolpuri Industrial Area resulted in four fatalities and two injuries. The factory had valid licenses and a NOC from the pollution control committee. Initial investigations suggested negligence by laborers as a potential fire cause, although further inquiries are ongoing. The Delhi Fire Service deployed multiple fire tenders to control the blaze, which lasted several hours.